Classical MechanicsBSc · Notes

Hints and solutions

Return to the problems.

F1 · Problem F1

Hint. Keep UtUt in actual motion but freeze time in a virtual variation.

Show worked solution

v=(q˙,2cqq˙+U)\mathbf v=(\dot q,2cq\dot q+U) and δr=(1,2cq)δq\delta\mathbf r=(1,2cq)\delta q. Hence T=m[q˙2+(2cqq˙+U)2]/2T=m[\dot q^2+(2cq\dot q+U)^2]/2, V=mg(cq2+Ut)V=mg(cq^2+Ut), and Qq(g)=−2mgcqQ_q^{(g)}=-2mgcq if gravity is kept outside LL. With gravity in VV, use Qq=0Q_q=0. Then Lq˙=m(1+4c2q2)q˙+2mcqUL_{\dot q}=m(1+4c^2q^2)\dot q+2mcqU. Its time derivative is m(1+4c2q2)q¨+8mc2qq˙2+2mcUq˙m(1+4c^2q^2)\ddot q+8mc^2q\dot q^2+2mcU\dot q, while Lq=4mc2qq˙2+2mcUq˙−2mgcqL_q=4mc^2q\dot q^2+2mcU\dot q-2mgcq. Thus (1+4c2q2)q¨+4c2qq˙2+2gcq=0(1+4c^2q^2)\ddot q+4c^2q\dot q^2+2gcq=0. Constant vertical support speed does not enter the acceleration equation.

F2 · Problem F2

Hint. Change both coordinate and velocity consistently.

Show worked solution

T=ms˙2/2T=m\dot s^2/2, V=mga[1−cos⁡(s/a)]V=mga[1-\cos(s/a)], so ps=ms˙p_s=m\dot s and H=ps2/(2m)+mga[1−cos⁡(s/a)]H=p_s^2/(2m)+mga[1-\cos(s/a)]. The equation is s¨+gsin⁡(s/a)=0\ddot s+g\sin(s/a)=0. Since pθ=ma2θ˙=apsp_\theta=ma^2\dot\theta=ap_s, the canonical momenta have different dimensions but describe the same motion.

F3 · Problem F3

Hint. Include rotational kinetic energy before varying.

Show worked solution

Choose qq downward for m1m_1. Then T=[m1+m2+I/R2]q˙2/2T=[m_1+m_2+I/R^2]\dot q^2/2 because ω=q˙/R\omega=\dot q/R, and V=−(m1−m2)gqV=-(m_1-m_2)gq. Thus q¨=(m1−m2)g/[m1+m2+I/R2]\ddot q=(m_1-m_2)g/[m_1+m_2+I/R^2]. Pulley inertia reduces the acceleration; unequal tensions supply its torque.

F4 · Problem F4

Hint. Treat ma2ma^2 as the angular inertia.

Show worked solution

L=ma2θ˙2/2−mgaθ2/2L=ma^2\dot\theta^2/2-mga\theta^2/2 in the small-angle approximation. With Qθ=τ0cos⁡Ωt−bθ˙Q_\theta=\tau_0\cos\Omega t-b\dot\theta, the equation is ma2θ¨+bθ˙+mgaθ=τ0cos⁡Ωtma^2\ddot\theta+b\dot\theta+mga\theta=\tau_0\cos\Omega t. Resolving cosine and sine terms gives angular amplitude Θ=τ0/(mga−ma2Ω2)2+b2Ω2\Theta=\tau_0/\sqrt{(mga-ma^2\Omega^2)^2+b^2\Omega^2}. The approximation requires the resulting amplitude to remain small.

F5 · Problem F5

Hint. Use X=(x+y)/2X=(x+y)/2 and s=x−ys=x-y.

Show worked solution

T=mX˙2+ms˙2/4T=m\dot X^2+m\dot s^2/4, V=ks2/2V=ks^2/2. Thus PX=2mX˙P_X=2m\dot X is conserved and X=X0+V0tX=X_0+V_0t. The relative equation is (m/2)s¨+ks=0(m/2)\ddot s+ks=0, with frequency 2k/m\sqrt{2k/m}. The original positions are x=X+s/2x=X+s/2, y=X−s/2y=X-s/2.

F6 · Problem F6

Hint. When differentiating HH, hold momentum fixed.

Show worked solution

p=aq˙p=a\dot q and H=p2/(2a)+VH=p^2/(2a)+V. Thus q˙=p/a\dot q=p/a and p˙=p2a′/(2a2)−V′\dot p=p^2a^{\prime}/(2a^2)-V^{\prime}. But p˙=aq¨+a′q˙2\dot p=a\ddot q+a^{\prime}\dot q^2, and p2/a2=q˙2p^2/a^2=\dot q^2. Therefore aq¨+12a′q˙2+V′=0a\ddot q+\tfrac12a^{\prime}\dot q^2+V^{\prime}=0, agreeing with the Lagrangian calculation.

F7 · Problem F7

Hint. Use the full translating-coordinate velocity.

Show worked solution

L=m(q˙+X˙)2/2L=m(\dot q+\dot X)^2/2, p=m(q˙+X˙)=mx˙p=m(\dot q+\dot X)=m\dot x. Thus H=p2/(2m)−pX˙H=p^2/(2m)-p\dot X. Hamilton’s equations give q˙=p/m−X˙\dot q=p/m-\dot X and p˙=0\dot p=0. Laboratory momentum and energy remain constant, but H˙=−pX¨\dot H=-p\ddot X when the coordinate origin accelerates.

F8 · Problem F8

Hint. Compare allowed momenta with the maximum potential.

Show worked solution

For E<2mgaE<2mga, two finite angle turning points give oscillation loops around the lower equilibrium. At equality the separatrix approaches the upper saddle asymptotically. Above it, momentum does not reverse and the rod pendulum rotates. A string can go slack unless tension remains nonnegative; the rod phase portrait alone does not enforce that inequality.

F9 · Problem F9

Hint. Use V′=anrn−1V^{\prime}=anr^{n-1}.

Show worked solution

The circular condition is ℓ2/μ=anrcn+2\ell^2/\mu=anr_c^{n+2}. Since rV′′/V′=n−1rV^{\prime\prime}/V^{\prime}=n-1, ωr2/Ω2=n+2\omega_r^2/\Omega^2=n+2. It is linearly stable when n+2>0n+2>0, unstable when n+2<0n+2<0, and marginal at equality. The given condition an>0an>0 ensures attraction.

F10 · Problem F10

Hint. The second derivative test is inconclusive, but the leading potential term has a sign.

Show worked solution

The quadratic curvature vanishes, so a linear frequency test says nothing. The leading quartic term is a local minimum. For sufficiently small excess energy, μη˙2/2+Aη4\mu\dot\eta^2/2+A\eta^4 confines the radial motion near zero. It is locally stable with amplitude-dependent, non-harmonic oscillations, assuming the higher terms do not remove the local minimum.

F11 · Problem F11

Hint. The initial radial velocity is zero.

Show worked solution

E=3/4−1=−1/4E=3/4-1=-1/4, ℓ=3/2\ell=\sqrt{3/2}, and e2=1+2(−1/4)(3/2)=1/4e^2=1+2(-1/4)(3/2)=1/4. Thus e=1/2e=1/2, a=2a=2, and ra=3r_a=3. The initial point is periapsis. The period is τ=2πμa3/k=4π2\tau=2\pi\sqrt{\mu a^3/k}=4\pi\sqrt2 in the associated time units.

F12 · Problem F12

Hint. The relative radius is dd, while each individual radius is d/2d/2.

Show worked solution

k/μ=2Gmk/\mu=2Gm, so Ω2=2Gm/d3\Omega^2=2Gm/d^3 and τ=2πd3/(2Gm)\tau=2\pi\sqrt{d^3/(2Gm)}. Each body has speed Ωd/2=Gm/(2d)\Omega d/2=\sqrt{Gm/(2d)}. Their relative speed is twice this value.

F13 · Problem F13

Hint. Equal angular momentum means equal semi-latus rectum.

Show worked solution

p=rc=a(1−e2)=0.36ap=r_c=a(1-e^2)=0.36a, so a=25rc/9a=25r_c/9. The period ratio is (a/rc)3/2=(25/9)3/2=125/27≃4.63(a/r_c)^{3/2}=(25/9)^{3/2}=125/27\simeq4.63. Energy is less negative than the circular minimum at that fixed angular momentum.

F14 · Problem F14

Hint. The radial momentum contributes to the vector’s transverse component.

Show worked solution

L=(0,0,1)\mathbf L=(0,0,1) and p×L=(1,−1/2,0)\mathbf p\times\mathbf L=(1,-1/2,0). Subtracting r^\hat{\mathbf r} gives A=(0,−1/2,0)\mathbf A=(0,-1/2,0), so e=1/2e=1/2 and periapsis points along −y-y. Energy is (1/4+1)/2−1=−3/8(1/4+1)/2-1=-3/8, giving a=4/3a=4/3. The positive radial speed confirms the particle is moving outward from that periapsis.

F15 · Problem F15

Hint. Hold bimpv∞2b_{\rm imp}v_\infty^2 fixed.

Show worked solution

The relation tan⁡(χ/2)=k/(μbimpv∞2)\tan(\chi/2)=k/(\mu b_{\rm imp}v_\infty^2) gives bimp,new=bimp,old/4b_{\rm imp,new}=b_{\rm imp,old}/4 when speed doubles, for the same masses and force constant.

F16 · Problem F16

Hint. Separate central-force properties from inverse-square special properties.

Show worked solution

Angular momentum remains constant because torque is still zero; planarity and area rate survive. Total energy in the full perturbed potential remains constant because it is time-independent. The inverse-square Runge–Lenz vector generally changes, with A˙=δFr^×L\dot{\mathbf A}=\delta F\hat{\mathbf r}\times\mathbf L. Thus a fixed orbital plane does not guarantee a fixed apsidal direction.

Search the notes

Search all four units and the course references.